There's been a lot of heat in the blogosphere this week, mice. It makes me think it's time to state a few things out loud, because people all over are expressing their hurt feelings over other people's opinions. It goes sort of like this:Blogger (any of us, really): "I, personally, don't care for having a goat as flower girl."*
Commenter: "Blogger, you have hurt me so deeply. In my family, goats are a time-honored tradition and it would break the hearts of my parents not to have a goat. And I really like goats. How could you have said something so hurtful?"
And then said Blogger takes it to heart, worrying that she has upset goat-lovers all over the internet and that not liking goats makes her a bad person on some level. Or she poses a hypothetical about goats, noting frantically in the footnotes that this isn't her opinion, but just something someone else said. Clearly, we're all anticipating those critical comments.
But you know what? No matter how emotionally charged wedding decisions are, most of them boil down to opinion and taste. They are PERSONAL. Blogging means coming up with opinions and articulating them in print.
Can't we, as a community of independent, free-thinking women (and occasional men), get behind the idea that we're actually not all trying to achieve the same thing? Can't we see all weddings--a big wedding, a small wedding, an inexpensive wedding, a glam wedding--as beautiful in terms of the people who are getting married?
For me, the goal isn't to direct style or shape my readers or pass judgment on what you guys want. I, personally, hate chair covers. I bet lots of you will have them. Maybe you like how they look, maybe your mother really wanted them, or maybe you're stuck with them because of the venue. But we can still be friends if I express my opinion, right? And you won't take it as a judgment on your style?
I'm not religious, but I find church ceremonies beautiful and moving. I hate big poufy veils on me, but I love brides who rock them. I don't care for jazz music, but if you love it, I think it's perfect for your ceremony.
So a goat flower girl, or whatever other decisions you make, will be wonderful if they come from conscious choice. This covers everything from "I think it will be pretty" to "It's what I can afford" to "My mother likes it" to "It reminds me of my favorite childhood memory." The point is that it comes from the two people getting married, and that you choose it because you want to.
The only stuff I'm down on is the stuff people choose because they feel like they have to, because they're pummeled with the unhealthy expectations of glossy magazines, or because the people on The Knot boards say their marriage won't mean anything without this or that detail. That I abhor. But if you choose things cause you want them, then I say GO YOU.
* Obviously a hypothetical example, since a goat flower girl would be AWESOME.





13 comments:
Great post, I think you bring up a good point. A lot of us have come to the wedding blog atmosphere in search of something more encouraging than The Knot or bridal magazines. We want to be involved in a community where there's no pressure to have 500 guests, a 4 course meal and an open bar. But for me, the blogging community been a double edged sword. Yes, I'm happy to feel encouraged and away from $50,000 wedding budgets, but I've also felt like I'm not as hip as I should be. Maybe I'm not doing enough DIY stuff, not being eco-friendly enough, or that I don't have a small enough budget. I think the blogging community does have a tendency to judge people who have large budgets or who aren't having DIY filled weddings. The same way that The Knot would judge others for having a potluck wedding. But like you said, we need to come to terms with the fact that we're all trying to achieve different goals. That no two weddings will be alike and that we should just be there to support one another.
Definitely a great post! After discovering the world of blogging I frequently came across comments of people offended by a statement in a blog post, yet I was unsure if most people were really this hurt by bloggers or if it was really just an over-reaction. I've never been one to mind other's opinions so I love hearing the disagreements and interesting topics that come up on the blogs, I just hate it when the comment section turns into world war three. Thanks for this post!!!
A+.
Yes. We are not all trying to achieve the same thing and we shouldn't be. That's missing sometimes, from blogger discourse, eh?
p.s. I really enjoy your writing & your style, keep it up!
Yep. I think people just touchy about wedding choices and there's a tendency to over react.
Here's my thing - I know what is right for me, but that doesn't imply judgment of anyone else.
And I have LOVED every single wedding I've ever been to, even the ones that were polar opposites of what I envision for myself. Because weddings are generally awesome.
Amen Mouse! Please continue with your animal analogies. They make me giggle with delight!
And a good point too. Let's all support each other regardless of our personal tastes. We should be in this together.
Yes.
Amen x 7,900. This should be an unspoken rule, that we all have different goals and opinions and that no one means any harm. Where it gets messy sometimes is when opinion turns into condemnation. Someone might say, "People who choose goats as flower girls are SO STUPID. that is SUCH A STUPID thing to do." Yeah, that I could see being offensive. And rude. This is when we stop reading that blog, or delete that comment. Keep the focus on the harmony, and celebrating all of our different choices!
Amen.
So far no one has wanted to lynch me yet. I am not that cool apparently.
I consider my first hate mail as my I-have-made-it mail.
Though I probably will cry because I want everyone to love me.
Sigh. As someone who has inspired a lot of hate mail. I applaud this wholeheartedly. People are such insecure assholes sometimes.
I feel like I probably deserve this comment, because I got kind of upset by the small wedding that got posted on a few blogs this week - a wedding that was beautiful and lovely; but that was also held up to us as an example of what we should strive for, or a reminder of what wedding planning is all about. And the problem I had wasn't the example. The problem I had was with the judgment I felt, which may have been because like Miss Fancy Pants, I am insecure about my wedding not being hip or "anti" enough; and because there is all this pressure to have a small meaningful wedding. I think the most important thing about wedding planning to take away though, is what APW said this week: know thyself.
Yes, this. However, we as bloggers also have a responsibility to make it clear that these are opinions. Our firmly held opinions, yes, but that there is little judgment of others' opinions. We certainly need to create an atmosphere of openness. Dissent and conversation are important. Respect is important. Having a safe space to discuss firmly held opinions is important. Not getting offended in the comments is important. (Critical reading ability is important too, for easily offended commenters. But I don't know how to fix that. sigh.)
Mouse, you just put your finger on the thing that bugs/bugged me most about the wedding blogosphere -- the unwillingness to tolerate variations in opinion. My own pet theory is that the emphasis on "personalizing" our weddings leads us to over-identify with our choices. Hence, if lengthy soul-searching has led us to decide on a goat flower girl, and we read that someone else thinks that's a bit of an odd trend, we freak out and interpret it as an attack on our innermost selves and/or our relationship and chances of marital success.
I completely agree with A Los Angeles Love and lyn about making it clear when we're expressing opinions, and avoiding condemning the people who choose options that we don't care for. There's a difference between saying "I don't care for X, it's just not for me," and "anyone who does X is shallow and silly and a slave to bridal magazine trends." But what frequently frustrates me is how people are so willing to take offense at the former kind of statement! Other peoples' tastes are not an attack on your tastes, or on you personally.
What can I say--I love you guys. It's wonderful to have such an open-minded group of people to talk things through with.
And I don't know how to get people to think critically, either, but it's not a bad mission. Maybe that should be the subhead: "Souris Mariage: Attempting to Get People to Approach Their Weddings as Critical Thinkers Who Don't Buy Any Preconceived Notions, Be They From Glossy Mags or the Hip Anti-s."
What do you think? Too wordy?
Ha ha. And xo.
Post a Comment